2 messages2007-08-31 14:14 UTCthrough 2007-08-31 17:17 UTC
Re: this sucks!
Alfred Poor2007-08-31 14:14 UTC
Tom chimed in:
"Question is, will licensing actually reduce accidents? I'm not sure
that is the case. Drunk driving is still a major cause of injury and
death in the US."
Hear, hear!!! As Connecticut's license program proves, a license is just a
piece of paper without the resources and will to enforce it. Even the
vaunted motor vehicle driver's license does not mean nearly as much as you
think it might; just wait until you get run into by an uninsured motorist,
or one driving on a suspended license. (I believe that the majority of
people with suspended or revoked licenses keep on driving. What are the
courts going to do, take their licenses away again?)
Our legislatures - federal, state, and local - are great at passing
restrictions and requirements, but not so good at setting up effective
enforcement. Those of us who choose to follow the laws - be it MSD
regulations or highway speed limits or paying our taxes - may face
inconvenience and expense. Those of us who choose to be unencumbered by such
restrictions often face little risk at being called to answer for our
actions.
It sucks, but that's one price we pay to live in this society. For the most
part, I'll accept it.
Alfred Poor
1969 Cal 29 #132, "Pentaquod"
Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: this sucks!
Chris Campbell2007-08-31 17:17 UTC
Alfred Poor wrote:
>
>
>
>
> Our legislatures --- federal, state, and local --- are great at
> passing restrictions and requirements, but not so good at setting up
> effective enforcement. T
>
As I pointed out earlier, Michigan has seen some improvements in the
drunk-driving statistics since it began better enforcement by letting a
lower drunk-driving blood-alcohol level, making it a lot harder to
decline breath tests, and by creating mandatory sanctions. When people
started going to jail, others took notice and the designated driver
became more common for drinking excursions. It can be done.
Of course, there will always be scofflaws. But murder is illegal and
that law is usually enforced with some enthusiasm, and people still do
it. What the laws can do about lesser bad behavior is to affect the
great bulk of us who would prefer not to incur legal penalties. The key
is effective enforcement. The laws that get enforced are those that
most directly affect people, usually. If you're in a community where
boating safety issues are arising often enough to get public attention,
the likelihood of enforcement goes up. Enforcement can work. It just
takes some political will or political pressure.
Chris Campbell