8 messages2008-04-17 17:52 UTCthrough 2008-04-17 21:58 UTC
Re: PFDs
C. Peter Audet2008-04-17 17:52 UTC
My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the rain. Nuisance! We have the built-in safety harness version, which I think is a good idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow these (armed) aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience. Anybody? I kinda like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a little padding from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch strap, they can float around your ears otherwise.
Peter
"Bribon" Cal 39
Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
Mike2008-04-17 18:05 UTC
Beth and I tried to take ours to Tahiti with us for our Moorings charter
and the airline took the cartridges from us even though the pfd was
unarmed. The dumbasses (Air Tahiti Nui) use the same cartridge for
their own life preservers. Needless to say it cost us a little bit when
we got back. :-(
Mike
C. Peter Audet wrote:
>
> My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the rain. Nuisance!
> We have the built-in safety harness version, which I think is a good
> idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow these (armed)
> aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience. Anybody? I kinda
> like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a little padding
> from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch strap, they can
> float around your ears otherwise.
> Peter
> "Bribon" Cal 39
>
Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
Chris Campbell2008-04-17 18:22 UTC
C. Peter Audet wrote:
>
> My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the rain. Nuisance!
> We have the built-in safety harness version, which I think is a good
> idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow these (armed)
> aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience. Anybody? I kinda
> like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a little padding
> from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch strap, they can
> float around your ears otherwise.
I think PFDs are like Lifeslings--you should try 'em out before an
emergency arises.
Two boat groups I volunteer with used to hold a joint in-the-pool safety
event. That's where I found out how hard it can be to climb into even a
dinghy with very little freeboard, if it lacks handholds to grab onto
and pull up with. And that was in a warm, comfy, calm pool. This was
one lesson that got me to wearing a PFD more often when sailing. The
things that you assume to be easy can be surprisingly hard in actual
practice. If I can't climb into a little dinghy, what chance would I
ever have of climbing back up onto my sailboat? (Note to self: work on
a rope ladder to trail overboard when sailing this summer!)
How your PFD fits you can be another surprise. My kayak one lacks a
crotch strap but does have a strap that cinches at the bottom, under my
ribcage, and seems to prevent it from riding up while floating (haven't
been in the water with it for a while).
Chris Campbell
Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
Chris Campbell2008-04-17 18:28 UTC
Mike wrote:
>
> Beth and I tried to take ours to Tahiti with us for our Moorings charter
> and the airline took the cartridges from us even though the pfd was
> unarmed.
>
On our last go-round on this subject, wasn't it our conclusion that you
should ship the cartridges ahead so they are there to greet you when you
arrive? It's like the concept of taking a little carry-on bag with a
change of clothes on the plane, and shipping the rest of your luggage
ahead so (a) it can't be lost and (b) you aren't accused of terrorism
for carrying shampoo. Of course, those who observe my hairdo (or lack
thereof) might wonder why I'd be carrying shampoo anyway, but that's
another subject.
Chris Campbell
RE: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
r good2008-04-17 21:33 UTC
on our recent trip to Florida, we confirmed that the security folks say its OK to take them on board an airplane, but each airline is allowed to say yea or nea. Delta? nea. found a neighbor lady at eh airport to hold them for us 'til we returned otherwise thay would have been discarded.
Reggie
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.comFrom: cl… [at] charterinternet.comDate: Thu, 17 Apr 2008 14:28:45 -0400Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
Mike wrote:
Beth and I tried to take ours to Tahiti with us for our Moorings charter and the airline took the cartridges from us even though the pfd was unarmed. On our last go-round on this subject, wasn't it our conclusion that you should ship the cartridges ahead so they are there to greet you when you arrive? It's like the concept of taking a little carry-on bag with a change of clothes on the plane, and shipping the rest of your luggage ahead so (a) it can't be lost and (b) you aren't accused of terrorism for carrying shampoo. Of course, those who observe my hairdo (or lack thereof) might wonder why I'd be carrying shampoo anyway, but that's another subject.Chris Campbell
RE: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
r good2008-04-17 21:38 UTC
several summers ago, 5 of us were swimming from our T2 on a warm summer evening at anchor. calm water and virtuallu windless. Rope ladder with plastic steps deployed before we all jumped in. You all know the type?
None of us could climb it back into the boat. I suggest not counting on this type unless you have tried it and found it useable. Part of the problem was hanging the ladder off the side of the boat and the hull curvature. You end up swinging under the boat. And toes and hands get pinched against the hull.
Reggie
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.comFrom: cl… [at] charterinternet.comDate: Thu, 17 Apr 2008 14:22:42 -0400Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
C. Peter Audet wrote:
My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the rain. Nuisance! We have the built-in safety harness version, which I think is a good idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow these (armed) aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience. Anybody? I kinda like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a little padding from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch strap, they can float around your ears otherwise.I think PFDs are like Lifeslings--you should try 'em out before an emergency arises. Two boat groups I volunteer with used to hold a joint in-the-pool safety event. That's where I found out how hard it can be to climb into even a dinghy with very little freeboard, if it lacks handholds to grab onto and pull up with. And that was in a warm, comfy, calm pool. This was one lesson that got me to wearing a PFD more often when sailing. The things that you assume to be easy can be surprisingly hard in actual practice. If I can't climb into a little dinghy, what chance would I ever have of climbing back up onto my sailboat? (Note to self: work on a rope ladder to trail overboard when sailing this summer!)How your PFD fits you can be another surprise. My kayak one lacks a crotch strap but does have a strap that cinches at the bottom, under my ribcage, and seems to prevent it from riding up while floating (haven't been in the water with it for a while). Chris Campbell
RE: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
r good2008-04-17 21:41 UTC
integral harness is best. crotch strap whould be mandatory. jmho.
Reggie
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.comFrom: cp… [at] sympatico.caDate: Thu, 17 Apr 2008 13:52:38 -0400Subject: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the rain. Nuisance! We have the built-in safety harness version, which I think is a good idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow these (armed) aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience. Anybody? I kinda like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a little padding from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch strap, they can float around your ears otherwise.
Peter
"Bribon" Cal 39
RE: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
Husar, Charlie [USA]2008-04-17 21:58 UTC
Very familiar, Reg. The ropers are useless (especially if there is no
one aboard to help haul you up). Makes for an interesting question on
haw a solo sailor gets back in the boat.
Cheers
Charlie
From: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com [mailto:Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of r good
Sent: Thursday, April 17, 2008 5:39 PM
To: ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Subject: RE: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
several summers ago, 5 of us were swimming from our T2 on a warm summer
evening at anchor. calm water and virtuallu windless. Rope ladder with
plastic steps deployed before we all jumped in. You all know the type?
None of us could climb it back into the boat. I suggest not counting on
this type unless you have tried it and found it useable. Part of the
problem was hanging the ladder off the side of the boat and the hull
curvature. You end up swinging under the boat. And toes and hands get
pinched against the hull.
Reggie
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
From: cl… [at] charterinternet.com
Date: Thu, 17 Apr 2008 14:22:42 -0400
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Re: PFDs
C. Peter Audet wrote:
My wife's Sospenders auto-inflatable inflated in the
rain. Nuisance! We have the built-in safety harness version, which I
think is a good idea. I have heard that the airlines will not allow
these (armed) aboard flights, but have no first-hand experience.
Anybody? I kinda like the vest/jacket type of PFD, since they provide a
little padding from seatbacks, etc. They really should have a crotch
strap, they can float around your ears otherwise.
I think PFDs are like Lifeslings--you should try 'em out before
an emergency arises.
Two boat groups I volunteer with used to hold a joint
in-the-pool safety event. That's where I found out how hard it can be
to climb into even a dinghy with very little freeboard, if it lacks
handholds to grab onto and pull up with. And that was in a warm,
comfy, calm pool. This was one lesson that got me to wearing a PFD more
often when sailing. The things that you assume to be easy can be
surprisingly hard in actual practice. If I can't climb into a little
dinghy, what chance would I ever have of climbing back up onto my
sailboat? (Note to self: work on a rope ladder to trail overboard when
sailing this summer!)
How your PFD fits you can be another surprise. My kayak one
lacks a crotch strap but does have a strap that cinches at the bottom,
under my ribcage, and seems to prevent it from riding up while floating
(haven't been in the water with it for a while).
Chris Campbell