3 messages2008-06-09 17:35 UTCthrough 2008-06-10 02:02 UTC
FW: Dead Regatta Sailor Hailed a 'Hero' for Helping Save 5 Other Mates
Husar, Charlie [USA]2008-06-09 17:35 UTC
An FYI, Folks.
Take Care
Charlie
From: in… [at] foxnewsmail.com [mailto:in… [at] foxnewsmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, June 10, 2008 2:41 AM
To: Staller, Phillip B
Subject: Dead Regatta Sailor Hailed a 'Hero' for Helping Save 5 Other
Mates
ph… [at] hud.gov has sent you the following link to a story at
foxnews.com: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,364454,00.html
Re: [Cal_Boats] FW: Dead Regatta Sailor Hailed a 'Hero' for Helping Save 5 Other Mates
Chris Campbell2008-06-09 18:39 UTC
Husar, Charlie [USA] wrote:
>
>
> An FYI, Folks.
>
> Take Care
> Charlie
>
>
> Subject: Dead Regatta Sailor Hailed a 'Hero' for Helping Save 5 Other
> Mates
>
> <mailto:phillip.b.staller%40hud.gov>
>
Wow, another melancholy tale of heroism and death. Studies have shown
that people who watch local TV news have a tendency to overestimate the
incidence of violence in their own communities, because it picks up
sensational stories from elsewhere. For sailors, the effect is probably
beneficial, because it makes us more aware of the opportunities for
disaster and perhaps more careful.
But I note that the keel fell off. Pardon me, but this modern tendency
for keels to fall off offends me. One of the fundamental issues in
going to sea is doing so in vessels that are suited to the task at
hand. It's why we've had those interminable arguments about bronze vs.
Marelon for seacocks and through-hulls, or previously, about fin vs.
full-keel design, or spade vs. keel-hung rudders. How much can you
depart from previously accepted safety practice without giving up too
much? Our own Mr. Lapworth helped to teach a lesson in openness to
innovation. But his boats don't have breaking keels or rudders, at
least not before they reached advanced age and keels got floppy and
stainless rudder components got corroded. Those are more like
maintenance issues. It just seems to me that ocean racing vessels
shouldn't have keels that fall off.
Chris Campbell
RE: [Cal_Boats] FW: Dead Regatta Sailor Hailed a 'Hero' for Helping Save 5 Other Mates
george macon2008-06-10 02:02 UTC
Agree w/ Chris...
Does seem a lot of boats have had trouble keeping their keels attached, but more importantly, sailors not keeping their PFD's on...
Now you can invite friends from Facebook and other groups to join you on Windows Live™ Messenger. Add now.
https://www.invite2messenger.net/im/?source=TXT_EML_WLH_AddNow_Now