18 messages2010-07-03 16:55 UTCthrough 2010-07-07 11:32 UTC
Storm hood
chris1232010-07-03 16:55 UTC
Greets;
Was wondering is anyone has build or installed a solid sea hood for
their boat. Currently working on some design concepts for the 3-29 and
the best idea so far is to completely remove the wooden outside
runners, which would necessitate replacing the sliding hatch cover or
converting it to run on SS runners mounted onto the fiber glass
integrated runners that are molded into the deck. Or building a new
one out of wood. The two boats that I have looked at who's designs I
like are the ericsons for a wooden cover and cape dory for an
integrated sea hood.
The reason for this need is that on the CAL3-29 the forward edge of
the sliding hatch cover is approx 1/4 to 1/8 open to the deck and the
trailing edge (at the hatch boards) is approx 1/4 gap. Its a real
bugger in the winter to deal with and a real good source for water
egress while underway. A dodger is good but not a good solution for
these issues.
Best regards
--
/ch
Re: Storm hood
chris1232010-07-03 17:10 UTC
Sorry forgot to mention the third option, and that is to add a storm
hood that is integrated and covers the existing wooden runners, adding
teak faceplate to the exiting hatch covers front edge to deal with the
gaps around the runners. Then increase the teak trim elements on the
companionway so it all mates up. This I think is the most complex
method, but the cleanest when it comes to original look.
Best regards
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
David Wilkie Owen2010-07-03 18:15 UTC
Been thinking about doing this for a while. Was even contemplating
making a plug and seeing who else was interested. The late and
beloved Roger Jones was into vacuum forming and he and I traded some
notes on building a system. I have the pump and various components
but ran out of energy a while back and the project has stalled.
Keep us up on what you plan to do....
Wilkie
On Jul 3, 2010, at 9:55 AM, chris123 wrote:
> Greets;
>
> Was wondering is anyone has build or installed a solid sea hood for
> their boat. Currently working on some design concepts for the 3-29 and
> the best idea so far is to completely remove the wooden outside
> runners, which would necessitate replacing the sliding hatch cover or
> converting it to run on SS runners mounted onto the fiber glass
> integrated runners that are molded into the deck. Or building a new
> one out of wood. The two boats that I have looked at who's designs I
> like are the ericsons for a wooden cover and cape dory for an
> integrated sea hood.
>
> The reason for this need is that on the CAL3-29 the forward edge of
> the sliding hatch cover is approx 1/4 to 1/8 open to the deck and the
> trailing edge (at the hatch boards) is approx 1/4 gap. Its a real
> bugger in the winter to deal with and a real good source for water
> egress while underway. A dodger is good but not a good solution for
> these issues.
>
> Best regards
>
> --
> /ch
>
>
RE: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
Harleigh Ewell2010-07-03 19:46 UTC
If anyone is interested in making a sea hood for a Cal 31, I would be
willing to chip in up to a few hundred bucks for one. (The companionway
is offset to starboard on the 31.)
Harleigh Ewell
From: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com [mailto:Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of David Wilkie Owen
Sent: Saturday, July 03, 2010 2:15 PM
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
Been thinking about doing this for a while. Was even contemplating
making a plug and seeing who else was interested. The late and beloved
Roger Jones was into vacuum forming and he and I traded some notes on
building a system. I have the pump and various components but ran out
of energy a while back and the project has stalled.
Keep us up on what you plan to do....
Wilkie
On Jul 3, 2010, at 9:55 AM, chris123 wrote:
Greets;
Was wondering is anyone has build or installed a solid sea hood for
their boat. Currently working on some design concepts for the 3-29 and
the best idea so far is to completely remove the wooden outside
runners, which would necessitate replacing the sliding hatch cover or
converting it to run on SS runners mounted onto the fiber glass
integrated runners that are molded into the deck. Or building a new
one out of wood. The two boats that I have looked at who's designs I
like are the ericsons for a wooden cover and cape dory for an
integrated sea hood.
The reason for this need is that on the CAL3-29 the forward edge of
the sliding hatch cover is approx 1/4 to 1/8 open to the deck and the
trailing edge (at the hatch boards) is approx 1/4 gap. Its a real
bugger in the winter to deal with and a real good source for water
egress while underway. A dodger is good but not a good solution for
these issues.
Best regards
--
/ch
__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus
signature database 5248 (20100703) __________
The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.
http://www.eset.com
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
david dobbs2010-07-04 02:55 UTC
Chris,
Good Old Boat magazine did a detailed article on how to build sea hoods a couple of issues ago. Check the website, but the actual paper copy is better. I have been thinking of building one also. It looks kinda complicated.
David Dobbs, Cal29 411
--- On Sat, 7/3/10, chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com> wrote:
From: chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com>
Subject: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Date: Saturday, July 3, 2010, 11:55 AM
Greets;
Was wondering is anyone has build or installed a solid sea hood for
their boat. Currently working on some design concepts for the 3-29 and
the best idea so far is to completely remove the wooden outside
runners, which would necessitate replacing the sliding hatch cover or
converting it to run on SS runners mounted onto the fiber glass
integrated runners that are molded into the deck. Or building a new
one out of wood. The two boats that I have looked at who's designs I
like are the ericsons for a wooden cover and cape dory for an
integrated sea hood.
The reason for this need is that on the CAL3-29 the forward edge of
the sliding hatch cover is approx 1/4 to 1/8 open to the deck and the
trailing edge (at the hatch boards) is approx 1/4 gap. Its a real
bugger in the winter to deal with and a real good source for water
egress while underway. A dodger is good but not a good solution for
these issues.
Best regards
--
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
chris1232010-07-05 17:07 UTC
Saw the online reference to that article but not in its entireity. Once I
draw up a set of plans will post them for comment if interested. The hardest
part I think is what to do with the teak sliders? If you remove them then
the hood has to be redisigned as well a the track that is sits on, the later
being simple the former not that simple. Any comments on this?
Best regards
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
chris1232010-07-05 18:37 UTC
This will be a winter project for me. The main objective right now is to get
the boat back home. The big design issue is not so much the sea hood rather
if the teak runners should be removed or not. Any comments on that Wilkie?
--
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
David Wilkie Owen2010-07-06 02:51 UTC
Agreed! The sketches I did last year incorporated the hood with new
hatch and sliders. Lots more joinery than I am used to and my
sketches were sub-standard an vague in that area. I have been meaning
to walk the docks for some inspiration.
Wilkie
On Jul 5, 2010, at 11:37 AM, chris123 wrote:
> This will be a winter project for me. The main objective right now
> is to get the boat back home. The big design issue is not so much
> the sea hood rather if the teak runners should be removed or not.
> Any comments on that Wilkie?
>
> --
> /ch
>
>
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
chris1232010-07-06 03:58 UTC
Interesting....did the same exercise. What I came back with is
basically variants on two themes...lets call them theme A: Island
Packet concept, theme B: deep water boats.
The island packet theme uses teak on the case plate forward leading
edge of the hatch to cover the hatch boards and teak side elements on
the companionway come to the same place as the top of the hatch. The
rail element of the hatch cover is a "C" routed into a separate wood
element attached to the hatch (wood or fibreglass) to catch the SS
slider. Some have an additional Teflon lets call it an upper slider to
decrease the friction on the two mating surfaces. The hatch is either
wood of glass, With this design the teak slider rails of the CAL 29
can be eliminated as the hatch moves back and forth held in place by
the "C" components of the hatches wood work.
The deep water boat theme is only differentiated by how the hatch
boards line up. The hatch covers front wood element is routed out to
receive the top hatch board so that it is flash but within a cavity,
so there is no overhanging lip to prevent water penetration. Its based
on a pressure fit. Again this design allows for the elimination of the
teak sliders to design and install the sea hood.
The design of the sea hood is really not that challenging as its
basically measurements to allow for adequate clearances and make sure
all the mating surfaces are in deed flush. Build it is of course a
different story. The only component that is unique from my reading is
that some form of drainage is required typically done by means of a
fillet on both sides of the sea hood, Some designs place it at the
front, some on the back. I guess the idea is to have it at the lowest
point for drainage. Where that would be on the 29 is probably boat
dependant as my roof is rather curved from years of walking on it...:)
Other 29's Ive inspected tend to be flatter.
Have some pictures somewhere of the Island packet's design....its
complicated alright, and see if I can dig them up.
Best and thanks
/ch.
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
chris1232010-07-06 14:22 UTC
Here are some pics on one mans effort to build a sea hood. While not
the same the pic's are good for study examples. The sea hood pics are
towards the bottom of the archive.
http://billsboat.webs.com/apps/photos/album?albumid=8960133
/ch
PS: its not a CAL....rather a unique little cruiser custom build in the States.
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
David Wilkie Owen2010-07-07 01:24 UTC
A detailed post that I am going to have to sober up before I digest.
Went to look at some IP photos though and I think it's an elegant
solution, if one can put the skills and patience together.
Wilkie
On Jul 5, 2010, at 8:58 PM, chris123 wrote:
> Interesting....did the same exercise. What I came back with is
> basically variants on two themes...lets call them theme A: Island
> Packet concept, theme B: deep water boats.
>
> The island packet theme uses teak on the case plate forward leading
> edge of the hatch to cover the hatch boards and teak side elements on
> the companionway come to the same place as the top of the hatch. The
> rail element of the hatch cover is a "C" routed into a separate wood
> element attached to the hatch (wood or fibreglass) to catch the SS
> slider. Some have an additional Teflon lets call it an upper slider to
> decrease the friction on the two mating surfaces. The hatch is either
> wood of glass, With this design the teak slider rails of the CAL 29
> can be eliminated as the hatch moves back and forth held in place by
> the "C" components of the hatches wood work.
>
> The deep water boat theme is only differentiated by how the hatch
> boards line up. The hatch covers front wood element is routed out to
> receive the top hatch board so that it is flash but within a cavity,
> so there is no overhanging lip to prevent water penetration. Its based
> on a pressure fit. Again this design allows for the elimination of the
> teak sliders to design and install the sea hood.
>
> The design of the sea hood is really not that challenging as its
> basically measurements to allow for adequate clearances and make sure
> all the mating surfaces are in deed flush. Build it is of course a
> different story. The only component that is unique from my reading is
> that some form of drainage is required typically done by means of a
> fillet on both sides of the sea hood, Some designs place it at the
> front, some on the back. I guess the idea is to have it at the lowest
> point for drainage. Where that would be on the 29 is probably boat
> dependant as my roof is rather curved from years of walking on it...:)
> Other 29's Ive inspected tend to be flatter.
>
> Have some pictures somewhere of the Island packet's design....its
> complicated alright, and see if I can dig them up.
>
> Best and thanks
>
> /ch.
>
>
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
chris1232010-07-07 01:34 UTC
The other thing that crossed my mind was this. Looking at CAL-36's on
yachtworld they seem to come with a sea hood stock. Noticeably the teak
runner are gone, which is interesting to me. Its not the best source as
there are currently only three on line. The one on craigslist in Florida was
recently sold and I did not grab the pictures. Dang....:)
Regards
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
david dobbs2010-07-07 01:41 UTC
Chris,
There are 2 Cal 31s on my dock, they both have sea hoods, and look stock to me, I'll be there tomorrow for racing, will take a closer look.
Regards,
David D.
--- On Tue, 7/6/10, chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com> wrote:
From: chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 8:34 PM
The other thing that crossed my mind was this. Looking at CAL-36's on yachtworld they seem to come with a sea hood stock. Noticeably the teak runner are gone, which is interesting to me. Its not the best source as there are currently only three on line. The one on craigslist in Florida was recently sold and I did not grab the pictures. Dang....:)
Regards
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Roger)
david dobbs2010-07-07 02:15 UTC
Boy,
This is one of those Roger Jones conversations. He would have been able to tell us why they put hoods on the 31, but not on the 29, and the reason for the decision. I miss his calm, informative presence.
Regards,
David D. Cal29 411
--- On Tue, 7/6/10, david dobbs <tm… [at] yahoo.com> wrote:
From: david dobbs <tm… [at] yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 8:41 PM
Chris,
There are 2 Cal 31s on my dock, they both have sea hoods, and look stock to me, I'll be there tomorrow for racing, will take a closer look.
Regards,
David D.
--- On Tue, 7/6/10, chris123 <chris.herrnberger@ gmail.com> wrote:
From: chris123 <chris.herrnberger@ gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood
To: Cal_Boats@yahoogrou ps.com
Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 8:34 PM
The other thing that crossed my mind was this. Looking at CAL-36's on yachtworld they seem to come with a sea hood stock. Noticeably the teak runner are gone, which is interesting to me. Its not the best source as there are currently only three on line. The one on craigslist in Florida was recently sold and I did not grab the pictures. Dang....:)
Regards
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
chris1232010-07-07 02:58 UTC
Thanks so much. Pic's would be wonderful if available.
/ch
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
scott2010-07-07 04:30 UTC
Chris
I also have looked at all the strom hood options
First a Dodger would be best
Second well because of the two step enrtry into the cabin and its angle of descend
well its ?? On a steeper companion way entry a a strom hood could work closer in to have
some affect
I looked at Roger Jones Idea but its a lot of work extended deck house and lots mods
to the inside to give the steep three or four set ladder down
Third the position of the storm hood or sea hood is of major concern you do not
want your head to hid it?
If you find a idea that works I'm sure all the 29 would love a solution,
What i have to keep the rain uot is canvas cover when the hatch is closed but open
SF is not a daily option I close the hatch shy the drop boards other wise
to much water can get in.
Scott
--- On Tue, 7/6/10, chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com> wrote:
From: chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 7:58 PM
Thanks so much. Pic's would be wonderful if available.
/ch
RE: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
Harleigh Ewell2010-07-07 05:11 UTC
I couldn't follow some of what you said, but a dodger and a sea hood
serve different purposes. Although when you have waves washing over the
cabin top, a sea hood may reduce the dripping of water into the cabin,
its main purpose is to keep the companionway hatch from being ripped off
by a wave that breaks onto the boat.
Harleigh Ewell
Cal 31
From: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com [mailto:Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of scott
Sent: Wednesday, July 07, 2010 12:31 AM
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
Chris
I also have looked at all the strom hood options
First a Dodger would be best
Second well because of the two step enrtry into the cabin and its angle
of descend
well its ?? On a steeper companion way entry a a strom hood could work
closer in to have
some affect
I looked at Roger Jones Idea but its a lot of work extended deck house
and lots mods
to the inside to give the steep three or four set ladder down
Third the position of the storm hood or sea hood is of major concern you
do not
want your head to hid it?
If you find a idea that works I'm sure all the 29 would love a solution,
What i have to keep the rain uot is canvas cover when the hatch is
closed but open
SF is not a daily option I close the hatch shy the drop boards other
wise
to much water can get in.
Scott
--- On Tue, 7/6/10, chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com> wrote:
From: chris123 <ch… [at] gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
To: Ca… [at] yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, July 6, 2010, 7:58 PM
Thanks so much. Pic's would be wonderful if available.
/ch
__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus
signature database 5257 (20100707) __________
The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.
http://www.eset.com
Re: [Cal_Boats] Storm hood(Chris H.)
chris1232010-07-07 11:32 UTC
I would tend to agree with this. However my needs are a bit different. Yes
this is one reason, the other being is that I travel in cold climates. The
leading edge of the hood lets it in so much air that I have to stuff it with
towels to keep the salon warm which are then frozen solid in the morning due
to condensate.
Secondly the front edge of the hatch (which I also need to rework) has a 1/4
inch gap between the runners, more towels are required to plug these. One
project that I will complete some day is to build an insulated interior
cover for the hatch that extends down over the washboards in two pieces, one
for the top, one for the boards connected via velcro and to the boat with
snaps. In this manner you can have a nicely insulated wind seal when it gets
cold and should help with the condensate.
Yup, had far too much time while stuck in the ice to work out all these
projects. But you do learn a lot, which is fun. A change of view out the
ports becomes a real treat. You tend to move vertical, 6 inches up and 6
inches down..:)
While a dodger is nice, I find it restricts the view. In a heavy blow she
has to come down any way. So at this point I see no need for it.
/ch